Transcript 0:00 [gentle music] Hello, and welcome to the Sport in Crypto podcast. Back again for another episode, a blockchain ticketing special. 0:17 And who else but Mike Saunders, the founder and CEO of XP, joining me on the show today. How are you, Mike? Hi. Thanks for having me. Why don't you tell people a little bit about yourself, your journey, and your career? 0:30 Uh, sure, sure. So, so my journey started at, in, in food delivery of all places. Uh, I started one of the first online food delivery companies back in the late '90s. 0:40 Uh, it was called campusfood.com because the only people with high-speed internet back then were, were in college. 0:46 Uh, that grew, uh, for over a decade, uh, into about 300 universities, and then we ultimately merged with, uh, GrubHub. 0:53 And I, uh, the rest of my journey was on the, on the GrubHub side, uh, creating this very large online marketplace for, uh, for food delivery. And, uh, uh, and I, 1:05 uh, got into ticketing, you know, a- after I left GrubHub because all of these online marketplace issues from my, my first, uh, my first career just kept on coming back. 1:15 And it just seemed like, like this is the wave where, where, uh, online marketplaces, the, the individual can, can, uh, can fight back and, and have more, uh, more advantages. That's really interesting. 1:27 And, and tell us more about what you're building now. Like, what is XP? So XP is a, is an innovative take on, on ticket resale, right? 1:35 So w- we really believe that, you know, the online marketplaces of the first generation really were more like classified sites where you'd list things and hope somebody comes. 1:45 And, and that lack of transparency really hurt the trust, right? The online marketplaces themselves could extract a really large, uh, large fees. 1:53 They, they could really hide the supply and demand to the point where the, the only real winner was the marketplace themselves. Can you explain to the audience 2:03 what e- what exactly are you folks doing on chain versus off chain? Sure. So we're letting basically strangers trade safely with each other. 2:12 And so f- to, for that to happen, you know, so much of the, the, the online marketplace world has kind of exited to Discord and Reddit and, and Facebook Marketplace, and there's a real concern of who goes first, right? 2:25 So what we want to provide, what we provide is basically, um, uh, escrow, where the, the, the money is safe on, on one side, and then the tickets, we attest the transfer on the other. 2:36 And so we're using the blockchain specifically for the stablecoin transfer. Very interesting. So the tickets themselves aren't on chain. They are not. They are not. Uh, you know, the tickets ultimately have to exit to... 2:46 You have to show somebody at the door. And, uh, and, and the, the primaries are, are very locked down with, uh, letting that exit out to an open system. 2:55 And so why has the stablecoin piece, uh, been an inflection point for you folks? So w- I think we, we've really, uh, started the flywheel by helping sellers, uh, get offers on their tickets. 3:09 So when a seller comes to XP and says, "Hey, I have these tickets for sale," they're getting instant offers. 3:15 They're basically getting bids, bids from a network of, uh, of fans and now- and mixed in with a network of pros that are looking to just offer immediate cash for tickets. 3:25 And the way to do that is to back that promise by, by, by stablecoins. It's the most efficient, fastest way to basically create an order book out of, uh, ticket resale. 3:34 So we're creating an on-chain order book for ticket resale using stablecoins, but the tickets are still off chain. We're like a one-sided... We, we, uh... Yes, yes. Is that what you set out to do? 3:45 I set out to disrupt the online marketplaces with this new tech. I knew it felt like there was an, an answer hiding in here. And I sometimes I... 3:55 you feel like the only way to jump in is just to jump into the deep end and, and see where, uh, where it lands. But this, this is the absolu... You know, this is a need. This isn't just a want for people. 4:04 And so let's, let's talk a little bit about how your experience is different for consumers compared to traditional secondary marketplaces. Sure. 4:13 So, uh, you know, the, the biggest difference, uh, specifically, you know, for all these sellers that, uh, that are trying to sell their ticket, uh, you know, I... 4:21 We see a lot more people trying to, you know, buy four tickets and only use two, or buy six tickets and, and use a couple. And so you have this kind of l- largely fragmented seller group of, of just individual fans. 4:34 And we're trying to take the uncertainty out of it. We're trying to say that "Hey, you know, the... There's a hidden demand that's out there currently on today's marketplaces." You don't really know who's buying. 4:44 You just have a list of, of asks from people selling tickets, right? StubHub is basically just a list of, of brokers' asks at the end of the day. 4:53 And by surfacing that hidden demand in the form of offers and bids, we think we get to s- real honest true price discovery and, and faster deals. Very interesting. 5:02 And we're gonna, we're gonna come back, Mike, to what you, where you wanna take this and what you wanna do in the future. 5:07 But I, I wanted to just do a bit of a, of a, a lay of the land of the ticketing landscape right now, particularly in America because I think, I think America's, you know, uh, where a lot of the, the, the kind of controversy and a lot of m- more live events happen. 5:20 Um, we've currently got, like, a couple of big lawsuits happening. 5:24 So, uh, StubHub's CEO has the Texas AG, Consumer Protection BC, and two class action lawsuits investigating against him because he, he basically was trading or scalping his own customers via StubHub, allegedly, I'll say for the record. 5:39 Um, there's a, there's a injunction, I guess, against, um, Ticketmaster as well. So would love for you to... A- and by the way, a lot of audience is not in the States. I think we're about 50% US. 5:49 So, um, being as high level as you can, explaining what is actually going on, um, as it pertains to, to ticketing in the United States right now. Sure. 5:58 Look, so on the primary side with, with Ticketmaster, um, like, well, tickets have never been h- hotter. Live events have never been hotter. Uh, you know, we're, we're seeing it everywhere. Uh, you know, the World Cup. 6:09 We're seeing it with, um, all of the, the summer concert tours. We just came off of the Knicks championship. Um, l- look- At the end of the day, Ticketmaster is the ticketing platform. 6:18 It's owned by Live Nation, which is the, the promoter. They own the venues. There's a monopoly here that was created a little over 10 years ago. 6:26 And so I think they're navigating how much, uh, you know, power do they influence over the industry. And the industries itself are, are evolving, right? 6:34 You know, how artists make their money is way more now based on tours than, than, than music streaming, right? So everything has been changing. 6:42 You have this monopolistic primary, and then you have these secondaries where, you know, really serve a, an important purpose on, you know, on putting tickets in the hands of the fans at the right moment. 6:54 So d- you know, just to, you know, put a point on this, Ticketmaster wants to sell their tour 10 months in advance, right? That's a lot of capital they need to guarantee early, early on in the cycle. 7:05 A lot of fans don't even think about this until two to four weeks before. So there's like a natural resale market that, that has to happen to r- You know, there, there is a price to get into an event, you know? 7:15 And, and so how does that discovery happen? Where does the, uh, you know, where do the trades happen, and, and who gets to control that price ultimately is, is where the, where the debate happens. 7:26 Right now on the blockchain ticketing side of things, right, there is this, um, idea that eventually people want to, like with other real-world assets, get things on-chain, right? 7:38 With, with tickets, I think that's a bit more difficult, right? Because these are things that require utility, right? It's not like putting gold or real estate or a fund on-chain. These things need to be used. 7:49 They need to be scanned. They need to be backwards compatible. And so as I see it, and, and Mike, maybe step in if you, if you think there's, um, there's a, a, another vantage view here. 8:00 But there's, you know, what was done a- at FIFA with the right to buy tickets, where you bought a on-chain token that gave you a right to buy or right to raffle, um, tickets, which, which is an interesting one, which I guess protects against bots because bots won't want something that is, like, negative EV in a kinda randomized way. 8:19 But they were also then dinged by some of the Swiss regulators that sort of thought this could be akin to gambling or, or break some gambling laws. 8:26 Um, you then have people that are trying to tokenize the secondary, which is, I guess, kinda similar to what you're doing, but maybe having a, a digital twin of the ticket on-chain and kinda doing what you would do with, like, a traditional RWA. 8:38 And then there's, um, uh, and then there's also people, yeah, trying to go, go all the way, which I think is, is much more difficult. 8:45 And I don't really understand how exactly you do that because, again, how do you solve the backwards compatibility? 8:50 It's not as much of a technical challenge as much as it's a, it's an everything challenge in th- you know, to really attack these industries, these incumbent industries. 8:59 You know, the, the way I see it, blockchain allows for the transfer of value. I think that was what's so exciting about, you know, me getting into the blockchain. You know, we, we... 9:07 And I don't know if I mentioned, like, we got into this, uh, earlier on where we won a Solana hackathon. We won the consumer track of the Solana, uh, Grizzlython a couple years ago. 9:16 W- just, uh, really trying to encode, like, value into, into NFTs to make them tradable. And that, that was the aha moment as well where, where these, these industries bridge. 9:27 Um, I think the minute you can transfer value on, you know, easily with strangers, if you squint, it looks like gambling. 9:33 If you squint, it looks like a lot of these other things where new primitives have to open up to allow people to trade safely. And so, you know, I think for me, this is such a large industry. 9:43 The, the players are, are billion-dollar players, and, and they have every incentive to, to keep, uh, innovators out. 9:49 And I j- I think the, the secondary wedge feels like the most, uh, obvious fragmented open wedge to, to kinda kickstart the flywheel. Very interesting. And so, uh, like, t- tell me, tell me a little bit more. 10:03 Y- you said that this, everything is difficult. It's not a technical problem. And I think I've written a bunch of times in sporting crypto that there's kind of 10:11 big product market fit potential but is a big business model issue when it comes to ticketing. I, I remember, and I say it a bunch of times, that, um, I knew someone at a sports league, uh, or a federation. 10:27 They s- they were really interested in blockchain ticketing. 10:30 Uh, and they said, "Oh, I nearly got this through, but then our, our chief commercial officer was like, 'How are you gonna replace the $8 million that we get a year from Live Nation?'" 10:38 And so i- is that what you were kind of, uh, referring to? Or what are, what are the other kinda intricacies and the difficulties of, of this, this kind of a subgenre of consumer crypto? There's two problems here, right? 10:50 You have the marketplace problem, which, which I'm... You know, I think marketplaces in general are uniquely very difficult business models. You know, the, the value is in the network that you create. 10:59 So that only gets stronger over time, right? And then to, you know, to your point on, you know, these promoters are writing very big checks to get the, the artists signed up 10 months in advance, right? 11:09 You have to pay the vendors. You have to... There's so much capital outlay, that it's really a capital formation problem. And everyone likes to, like, point at and blame, you know, ticket prices. 11:20 But, but at the end of the day, you know, Live Nation's job is to basically run a successful, in, in effect, IPO or ICO and, you know, getting, you know, even experimenting with, with variable pricing now o- on, on, on the, on the get-go to, to extract as much money as possible on the start to, to fill the ar- you know, arenas. 11:38 These artists don't want empty seats, right? There's ego involved. They, they can't, you know, be discounting tickets. But at the same time, you know, it, it, it's a hard demand-supply curve on a, on an expiring asset. 11:52 What are some of the things that you folks have done that has solved some of the pain points in the traditional industry? 11:59 So look, I think right now a lot of fans would w- would go to more shows if they thought, "Hey, if I can't go, I can, I can sell quickly." Or, like, th- there's this kind of fear of, like, 12:12 you know, there, there's a bit of a greed and fear. "Oh, I have these great tickets. Hey, maybe it's worth more." Or, "I have this great, uh, these great tickets. Well, I'm three days out, and they can go to zero." 12:21 So I just think that, you know- That is not healthy for normal fans to just make, you know, judgments far in advance. 12:29 And so giving, giving fans the ability to buy and then sell quickly if, if their plans change, I think is just, is just a lot of value. 12:38 And, and, you know, to the same extent, we're also offering fans the ability, hey, if you're tracking tickets, if you're, if you have five tabs open every day, you know, y- you can make a standing, you know, offer, and the minute something comes across our, you know, in effect, our order book, uh, you could pick it right up. 12:55 So we're basically trying to solve for liquidity here. 100%. This is a liquidity engine, uh, wrapped up in a, in a ticket marketplace. What are you looking to do next with, with, um, with XP? 13:06 Like, y- you've kinda found product market fit, I suppose, at this point. Um, where do you wanna take this? So we've absolutely found this product market fit. Uh, a- and 13:18 in certain events, and, and we're basically just growing the pool of events, right? So in a lot of ways, these are local liquidity pools, right? 13:25 Your, your ticket volume is very different in New York versus LA versus Chicago, right? And, and so, and there's really demand everywhere, right? 13:33 So, you know, I saw this on the food delivery is your, your New York food delivery v- was very different than your Cincinnati food delivery. Like, you need a different, different supply, different demand. 13:41 Local makes things harder. And I think the, the demand is everywhere across, across the internet. It's in all of these Reddit communities, all of these Facebook groups. 13:50 But really stitching together this disparate supply and connecting it to, like, a unified liquidity, uh, is, you know, w- will take some more time to, to, to deepen that liquidity pool. 14:02 And so you kinda have this, um, this obviously kind of like, uh, compounding effect, where the more people are involved, the more, the more, um, the more liquidity there, there is. 14:11 What are the different subtypes of customers that are in- involved in the order books? 14:16 And have you also had any, uh, interest from kinda more institutional players if you're able to kinda, like, uh, commoditize and financialize from a liquidity perspective and, and have actual, you know, order books? 14:29 Has there been interest across the spectrum beyond just pure consumers, or are you just trying to solve the issue for consumers? 14:35 Or can there be a world where, you know, uh, people can hedge exposure on specific venues, on specific, uh, performances, and so on and so forth? 14:45 I think the end state of this, you know, you should be able to hedge anything, right? 14:49 The end, end state, you know, maybe there's a Calci bet on will this performer cancel their tour as, as, as basically cancellation insurance that's priced in by the market. 14:58 Uh, you know, I think we've seen more institutions jump into ticketing as an asset class. We've seen more, uh, basically 15:07 a- algorithmic programmatic folks basically scraping everyone to try to, to in effect make their market because there's really no, um, you know, visibility on the order book. 15:18 You know, but I, I think it-- the, the future's actually brighter for fans. 15:21 You know, we have a, you know, if you go to xp.tickets/mcp, you know, we've launched an MCP that allows fans to have the same basic tooling that a, that a, an algorithmic would use, right? 15:34 So it's no longer you have to just kind of h- hope and, and, and wait and check in every day. The agents in the future, I think, work on your behalf, as basically many, many institutional traders on your behalf. 15:45 Have you gotten much uptake on the MCP and the agent, agentic side? It's early, and we, we see people experiment with it. But I, I think, uh, the experiments are pretty cool. 15:54 We've seen people really do really unique things. 15:56 Um, you know, uh, one group is, was basically, you know, building to your-- exactly to your, your point, like hedging off of this as well, where you could buy the ticket and hedge something else. 16:06 Uh, other, other folks are just using it as really advanced price and inventory alerts. Um, and then we, we see a lot of, like, early experimentation just kind of, you know... 16:15 It, it's a lot of just discovery on price, uh, and discovery on unique inventory when, when inventory drops. But, uh, I think we're still in the early days. 16:23 You know, we've seen so much happen in this kinda blockchain ticketing landscape since 2018. You know, I'm a, um... 16:29 One of good friends of the show, former sponsor Sandy, Sandy Khawam from Credenza, sold their blockchain ticketing company in 2018 to Ticketmaster. 16:36 And we're still getting ticket, uh, blockchain ticketing startups start today. Where do you think more broadly, stepping back, this, this kinda world goes, Mike? Again, I, I look at this from my online marketplace lens. 16:50 And, and all of these online marketplaces are basically fancy ma- matching engines and liquidity engines, right? At, at the end of the day, we're connecting buyers and sellers, right? 17:00 You know, we're connecting two sides of the market in the most efficient way possible. And so I think the blockchain tech solves for moving, moving money and moving value. 17:10 I think the other wave is, is all this agentic commerce where you don't have to think too hard. Your, your agent-- You can offload thinking to the agent, and the agent will work on your behalf. 17:20 So i- in a world where you have unlimited agents and concierges running around, you know, trading and, and trying to buy with real money, uh, real internet money, I, I think you just... all sorts of different, uh... 17:34 I, I think the world gets rewi- re- rewritten and, and marketplaces just look different, right? You know, from eBay to how I get a driver to, you know, all of the above. 17:44 I, I think it starts in ticketing, just because ticketing is-- you know, tickets are naturally native. You know, we have to right now attest one side of the transfer. 17:51 Because to your point, the, the money is on chain, the ticket's not. A- and that's not gonna change, uh, for the next, uh, next large, uh, concert series, uh, in a couple months. 18:00 Lastly from me, Mike, um, I'm curious to hear your thoughts on this, right? So we've seen this expos- explosion in the Gotcha space, right? Uh, you know, uh, packs, digital reselling, all on chain. 18:13 And, and again, that's something that's a utility, a collectible that people wanna hold and have, but they're storing it on vaults, and they're, they're, they're holding the, the, the NFT on the front end and trading that NFT on the front end too. 18:25 I guess with tickets it's a little bit different. You use it and then- It, it's done. I suppose, is there ever a world, and will this ever happen, where you have the entire, 18:36 uh, from inception to use is somewhat linked on chain or... and validates on chain so that the kinda like trustlessness of the blockchain can help solve for the biggest issue in ticketing, which is fraud? 18:50 Oh, I absolutely hope so. I absolutely expect it to happen at some point. Uh, I think I've, uh, I've... You know, I've learned over the years timing these things are, are very difficult. 19:00 And so I think you really have to be early so that you're on time. And so I think at some point, um, the primaries, the venues, the performers are going to want to be able to have more control over their tickets, right? 19:13 Uh, you know, whether it's royalties or whether it's just, you know, uh, you know... Yet the fans are gonna want transfer rights, and the blockchains are perfect for this, this stuff. 19:22 It just, like when you go to the, uh, you know, when you go to the venue, if, if you're, uh, if, if, if the blockchain's down or, or if things are slow, I mean, everything breaks. 19:31 So I think, you know, we have not had a performance issue. You know, we're, we're built on Solana. We haven't had a performance issue in, in, in years at this point, right? 19:38 You know, for a year and a half it's, it's been super smooth. Uh, but I think that the pipes in the, the stack below are evolving. And at some point it just... 19:47 You know, no one ever asks me what database I have anymore, right? Uh, this is... At some point the blockchain will just be that, that database that allows performers and venues and artists to c- have, have more control. 19:57 This was really great, Mike. I, I really can't wait to get this out and, and can't wait to do a writeup about it. Is there anything that I didn't ask you that you wanted to discuss? 20:05 You covered, you know, all of it from, you know, all the, all the concerns that we're seeing with, uh, you know, with StubHub, uh, you know, you're getting beaten up for, uh, you know, selling tickets they didn't have to, uh, to, you know, the future of tickets on chain. 20:16 This is great. Mike, uh, thanks so much for, uh, jumping on. Where can people find out more about you? Just go to xp.tickets and find me on, uh, X @saunders3000. 20:26 You can find me @peprisha, and you can find us @sportingcrypto or, or newsletter.sportingcrypto.com if you wanna subscribe. And please do leave us a like, review, and all that good stuff on the podcast and on YouTube. 20:37 And, uh, we'll have more Sporting Crypto content for you soon. [outro music]